Audi V. Shokan Coachworks: Trademark Infringement in Email Signature

February 28, 2009 by · Leave a Comment
Filed under: Blog 

Background:

 

Automobile manufacturer Audi AG (â??Audiâ?) had previously sued Shokan Coachworks Inc. (â??Shokanâ?), a vehicle recycler and used-parts retailer specializing in Audi parts, for trademark infringement in 1990 over Shokanâ??s use of the AUDI mark and logo on its letterhead, business cards and advertisements. The parties settled that lawsuit, with Shokan agreeing to change its logo and refrain from using the AUDI mark except as an adjective to describe its repair services.  The settlement also specifically approved a Shokan ad that used the phrase â??AUDI USED PARTSâ? and the phone number â??1-800-ALL-AUDI.â?

 

In 2003, Audi again sued Shokan for trademark and trade dress infringement, dilution, false designation of origin, false advertising, and cybersquatting. At issue were Shokanâ??s use of the phone number 1-800-ALL-AUDI; answering the Shokan business line â??all Audi;â? using the phrases â??Audi Used Partsâ? or â??Used Audi Partsâ? in ads; using the email address â??allaudi.shokan@verizon.net;â? (“email address”) using the phrase â??Shokan Audi Partsâ? in the signature block of 38,000 emails sent by Shokan; the doman name â??800allaudi.com;â? and the phrases â??Audi Parts Warehouseâ? amd â??1-800-ALL-AUDIâ? inside Shokanâ??s business premises. Audi also alleged that Shokan used Audiâ??s ring logo on its website and on a sign inside the business premises.

 

The parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment, with each party winning some and losing some. The opinion on all cross-motions is Audi v. Shokan Coachworks, Inc., 2008 WL 4911730, No. 1:07-CV-00173 (N.D.N.Y. 2008).

 

The doctrine of laches protected Shokan on previously-decided claims

 

Shokan asserted a laches defense regarding its use of 1-800-ALL-AUDI and in using â??Audi Used Partsâ? in advertisements, on the grounds that both were permitted in the partiesâ?? previous settlement agreement and had been used by Shokan for 20 years.

 

The court agreed with Shokan, finding that Audi had failed to show that Shokan exceeded the scope of usage contemplated by the original settlement agreement. The court rejected Audiâ??s argument that its prosecution delay was excusable, as Shokan had been using the phone number and advertising for so long that the delay prejudiced Shokan. 2008 WL 4911730, *10-13.

 

Improper authentication prevented summary judgment on email address

 

The court granted summary judgment in favor of Shokan on the email address â?? due to Audiâ??s failure to properly authenticate supporting documents. Audi submitted copies of Shokanâ??s website, which included the email address as contact information. However, Audi used the archive.org website to generate the submitted images supported by declaration of an Audi witness. Courts have held that printouts from archive.org can only be authenticated by a knowledgeable representative of that website. Audiâ??s failure to produce such a representative meant Audi failed to properly authenticate the printouts, which means the Court could not consider those printouts in support of Audiâ??s motion for summary judgment. 2008 WL 4911730, *24.

 

Likelihood of confusion and dilution created in email signature block

 

The court did grant summary judgment in favor of Audi on its infringement and dilution claims regarding Shokanâ??s use of the AUDI mark in its email signature block., â??Shokan Audi Parts.â? The court found that the signature block created a likelihood of consumer confusion based on the partiesâ?? competitive proximity, the strength of the AUDI mark, and Shokanâ??s use of the identical mark. 2008 WL 4911730, *19.

 

The court also agreed with Audiâ??s dilution argument regarding the signature block. The Audi mark was famous based on the length of time it had been registered, the high cost of Audiâ??s advertising campaigns, and the amount and geographic reach of Audiâ??s sales. The case was filed before enactment of the Trademark Dilution Revision Act, which establishes a â??likelihood of dilutionâ? standard, so the court applied the previously applicable â??actual dilutionâ? standard. Even with this higher standard, Audi established actual dilution as a matter of law because of Shokanâ??s use of the identical mark in its signature block. 2008 WL 4911730, *20

 

No nominative fair use by Shokan

 

The court rejected Shokanâ??s nominative fair use defense. The court followed the lead of many other district courts in the 2nd Circuit in following the 9th Circuit test â?? rather than the 3rd Circuit test — for nominative fair use (though the 2nd Circuit Court itself had not yet adopted any test for nominative fair use). The 9th Circuitâ??s three-part test for nominative fair use determines whether 1) the product or service in question is not readily identifiable without use of the trademark; 2) only so much of the marks are used as is reasonably necessary to identify the product or service; and 3) the user does nothing that would suggest sponsorship or endorsement by the trademark holder. 2008 WL 4911730, * 14-16.

 

The court determined that Shokanâ??s email signature block and its other uses of the â??Audiâ? mark could not qualify as nominative fair use because Shokanâ??s use could â??imply sponsorshipâ? by Audi, thus failing the third prong of the test. 2008 WL 4911730, *16.

 

Question of good faith in cybersquatting claim is a question of fact

 

As to the domain name â??800allaudi.com,â? there was as genuine issue of fact as to whether the prior settlement covered those claims. The prior settlement, allowing Shokan to use the vanity phone number, prevented the court from being able to find, as a matter of law, that Shokanâ??s use of the phone number as a domain name constituted bad faith under the Anticybersquatting Consumer Protection Act. The court specifically noted that issues such as good faith are â??singularly inappropriate for determination on summary judgment.â? 2008 WL 4911730, *21.

 

Conclusion

 

Shokan should serve as a sobering reminder for practitioners that printouts of historical websites from the archive.org website are not admissible without a supporting declaration from an archive.org representative. The case is also indicative of a trend of federal courts to adopt the 9th Circuit test for nominative fair use, as opposed to the 3rd Circuitâ??s different nominative fair use test.

 

Finally, the scope of the partiesâ?? previous settlement agreement had a significant impact on the outcome of these cross-motions. While Audi likely believed it was allowing narrow uses, Audiâ??s previous allowance of those uses raised questions of fact as to whether similar uses would also be allowed. Practitioners should learn from this case and take care to craft settlement agreements very narrowly to avoid a similar situation.

D. Dennis La
http://www.articlesbase.com/intellectual-property-articles/audi-v-shokan-coachworks-trademark-infringement-in-email-signature-754954.html

  •  

    The Perks of Colon Cleansing

    As more and more people suffer from the effects of unhealthy lifestyles and unhealthy diets, colon cleanses have steadily risen in popularity. Our bodies really need help in getting rid of the toxins that it can store and colon cleansing isjust the ticket, cleaning up our insides in the process! A good colon cleanse prevents the onset of constipation, and stops it altogether should you be prone to getting one. Doctors recommend a diet rich in fiber alongside a colon cleanse, to get rid of toxins and fecal matter, lessening the possibility of constipation.

    A healthy body and digestive system is the greatest benefit one can get from colon cleanses. However, ones that we can also rejoice to is that of weight loss. With the colon being able to carry 30 pounds of fecal matter, a colon cleanse can easily get rid of most, if not all of them, resulting in what seems to be instant weight loss!

    Excellent Sleep Aid Remedies

    The build-up of stress from work, relationships and home life can actually affect our sleep patterns, making us prone to sleep deprivation and sleep disorders. To counter sleep deprivation, sleep aid remediesare being marketed left and right. Different treatments work for different people, with some insomniacs finding relief from warm milk or prescription sleeping pills and anything in between. Herbal infusions, herbal teas and soothing baths have also marked a significant difference for those suffering with sleep deprivation. Before you may start thinking that any sleep deprivation treatment may be ok, heed warning! Over the counter pills are not all good! Some can cause serious harm, so, as with anything, caution is always required!

    Nipping Menopause Symptoms in the Bud

    For most women, it's not really the menopause symptoms that bothers them, but it's the hot flashes and night sweats, conditions that can really cause shame, embarrassment and insecurity!

    Plenty of women have reported about the effectiveness of Hot Flash freedom, a natural and safe progesterone cream designed to counter hot flashes and night sweats! Most if not all, have claimed a marked improvement of there menopausal symptoms. Hot Flash Freedom can definitely bring you the relief you so desire! Why not follow her route and try out the product for yourself?!

    Searching for the Ideal Dentist

    Searching for the ideal dentist to call your own? Don't worry, they are more common than you think! I have been going to my Glastonbury Dentist for years and I have always found his services to be impeccable. Friends in Richmond equally recommend Richmond Dentist, Dr, Charles Martin! They tell me he is among the excellent Richmond Dentists out there! For Quincy residents, Dr. Matazarro is the Quincy dentist to go to. Lastly, Kauai residents are lucky to have Kauai Dentist , Dr. Clyde Ishida. He has had a great track record, giving people great smiles and along that, priceless confidence!

    Easing the Stress on Retirement

    As for finding their new homes, there is always Assisted Living Decatur arrangement. There are plenty of wonderful communities that offer this type of arrangement, and they specifically cater to retirees. In these communities, it is not uncommon to fund golf courses California synthetic turf golf course greens. Now, how's that for modern living?

    Business Finance OptionsTo Finance Your Dream Business

    Are you a budding entrepreneur? Do you know that you can make your business dreams come true, not unlike these Flower Essences. Your great idea can be the next great thing if you act right away! Consult with a firm that will present you with business finance options! They will be able to talk to you about ways to get the capital that you need. You can start working for yourself, without even having to get a bank loan! Call them up and discover your options!

    Tips to a Successful Online Business

    Running a successful online business is not a game of chance. It takes some serious internet savvy to get you the traffic that you need. First, it is advisable to consult a website designer to create an unforgettable yet functional site for you. Then, there's Search Engine Optimization! You need that to get your website up on the search engine rankings. Get these two techiques right, and you should be sitting pretty like this Environmental Services Company. They've solved the puzzle of great online marketing!

    Travel, Tips and Treasures

    During special occasions, instead of looking around aimlessly for the perfect gifts, why not give out tickets instead! Tickets to their favorite sports game or a Disney Guide are certified crowd pleasers! Wisconsin Dells, the home of water parks and other family destinations is a sure crowd pleaser.

    Sourcing SportsTickets

    Online is always a great place to search for leaf tickets, Ranger Tickets,Celtic Tickets, Kings Tickets, Redwings Tickets, Dodger Tickets, Magic Tickets, Heat Tickets, Angels Tickets, Chargers tickets, Leafs Tickets, Nationals Tickets, Cardinal Tickets, Packers Tickets, Giant Tickets, Seahawk Tickets, Raven Tickets, Clippers Tickets, Chief Tickets, Thunder Tickets, Redskin Tickets, Cowboys Tickets, Texans Tickets, Raider Tickets, Viking Tickets, Dolphin Tickets and 49ers Tickets! You can get tickets without even leaving your home!
    I have grown accustomed to going online to buy my Ranger Tickets.It just never fails!

    Never Underestimate the Value of Professional Water Damage Cleanup

    I didn’t realize how much damage water could do until a pipe blew at our little car repair business. None of the heavy equipment was damaged but we had to stop operations during the water damage cleanup. I didn’t even know where to start and we generally just tried to put everything where they were supposed to be and mop up as much of the water as possible. After a couple of days of trying to assess the damage and getting things back to normal, I finally decided to try looking up a number that I could call to help us out. I found a water damage Orlando restoration company to call and thankfully they had 24 hour service. They gave me a free telephone consultation and also threw in a free visual inspection. Calling them was one of the best decisions I’ve ever made for my business. They got the repair shop back to normal in a lot less time than I expected and we were back in business before I knew it. They were definitely professionals and handled the water damage quickly and thoroughly. I took them up on their insurance billing services too. Not having to deal with insurance too much was a real load off, and it gave me more time to work on the repair shop. I’m glad I found a number to call for this kind of emergency. I would suggest that you look for a restoration services company now and have the number handy when the time comes that you need it.